1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. Remortgaging and rates

How to Compare the Best Mortgage Deals for You

Illingworth Mortgages13 July 20267 min read

Find the best mortgage deals for your circumstances with clear advice on rates, fees, lender criteria and choosing a product that supports your plans.

A low rate can look compelling on a comparison table, yet it may not be the mortgage that costs you least or gives you the flexibility you need. The best mortgage deals are the ones that suit your deposit or equity, income, plans for the property and the point at which you expect to move, remortgage or make overpayments.

For a first-time buyer, that may mean securing a competitive five-year fixed rate and keeping upfront costs manageable. For an existing homeowner, it could mean reducing the overall cost of a remortgage without being tied in for longer than necessary. The right answer is personal, which is why looking beyond the headline rate matters.

What the best mortgage deals actually look like

A mortgage deal is made up of more than an interest rate. The rate affects your monthly payment, but fees, incentives, early repayment charges and the product term can change the bigger picture considerably.

A product with a slightly higher rate and no arrangement fee may be better value than a lower-rate option carrying a large fee, particularly where the mortgage balance is modest or you expect to remortgage again in a couple of years. Conversely, paying a fee can make sense on a larger loan if the rate saving outweighs it over the deal period.

It is also worth separating the initial product period from the full mortgage term. A two- or five-year fixed deal is not usually the length of the mortgage itself. At the end of that fixed period, you will normally move to the lender’s standard variable rate unless you arrange a new product. That rate is often higher, so planning your next review early can help avoid an unnecessary increase in payments.

Start with your circumstances, not the rate table

Before comparing products, establish what a lender is likely to assess. Your income, regular commitments, credit history, deposit or equity and property type all influence the products available to you. Lenders also apply their own affordability calculations, and these can differ more than many borrowers expect.

The loan-to-value ratio, often shortened to LTV, is especially significant. It is the percentage you borrow compared with the property’s value. A £240,000 mortgage on a £300,000 home is an 80% LTV mortgage. Generally, lower LTV bands offer access to lower rates, although the cost of saving a larger deposit or reducing a mortgage balance should be considered alongside the potential saving.

For homeowners coming to the end of a fixed rate, an up-to-date property valuation can be useful. If house prices have risen or you have paid down more capital, you may have moved into a lower LTV band. On the other hand, do not rely on an optimistic estimate when planning. The lender will use its own valuation method.

Compare mortgage costs over the right period

When assessing the best mortgage deals, compare products over the period you expect to hold them, rather than focusing solely on the monthly payment. A sound comparison should account for the interest charged, product fee, valuation fee where applicable, legal fees and any cashback or remortgage incentive.

The annual percentage rate of charge, or APRC, is designed to show the cost of borrowing over the full term, including assumptions about future rates. It is useful context, but it is not always the best tool for choosing between two products when you know you will remortgage after the initial deal ends. In that case, the cost during the fixed or tracker period is often more relevant.

Also look closely at early repayment charges. These apply if you repay all or part of the mortgage beyond the permitted overpayment allowance while the deal is in place. They can be substantial. If you may sell the property, receive a bonus, inherit money or want to make a significant overpayment, flexibility could be worth more than the lowest available rate.

A clear comparison should answer practical questions, including:

  • What will the monthly payment be now, and could it change?
  • What are the fees, and can they be added to the loan?
  • How much interest and cost will arise during the product period?
  • What happens if you move home or repay early?
  • Does the lender allow the overpayments you may want to make?

Adding a fee to the mortgage can reduce the cash needed upfront, but interest is then charged on that fee for as long as it remains outstanding. Paying it separately may be more economical where affordable.

Choose the product type that fits your plans

Fixed-rate mortgages provide certainty: your interest rate and monthly repayments stay the same for the agreed period. They can be reassuring when household budgets are tight or when you simply want to know exactly what will leave your account each month. The trade-off is that early repayment charges are common, and you will not benefit if rates fall during the fixed term.

Tracker mortgages follow an external rate, usually the Bank of England base rate, plus a set margin. They may offer more flexibility and sometimes have lower or no early repayment charges, but payments can rise as well as fall. A tracker is best considered only where the budget can comfortably absorb a potential increase.

Discount and variable mortgages can also be suitable in particular circumstances, but their rates are set by the lender and may change. The right choice depends on your appetite for payment changes, the time you expect to stay in the property and whether flexibility has a real value to you.

For buy-to-let borrowers, the calculation is different again. Lenders will assess expected rental income as well as the borrower’s position, and product fees can be more prominent. Portfolio landlords, limited company borrowers and applicants with specialist property types may need lending that is not widely available on high-street comparison sites.

Lender criteria can be as important as price

The cheapest advertised mortgage is not always available to every applicant. A lender may have specific requirements for self-employed applicants, contractors, applicants with historic credit issues, flats above commercial premises, new-build homes or borrowers approaching retirement.

This is where an application can become frustrating if it has been approached only as a rate search. A product may look suitable until the lender’s underwriting criteria are considered. Finding a lender that understands your income structure or property type can save time and reduce the risk of an application being declined after you have incurred costs.

For self-employed borrowers, for example, lenders may use salary and dividends, net profit, retained profit or a varying combination depending on the business structure. For someone whose income has changed recently, the most appropriate lender may not be the one offering the lowest rate on paper.

Do not leave a remortgage until the last minute

Many lenders allow a new mortgage application to be arranged months before an existing deal ends. Starting early gives you time to review the market, gather documents and make a considered decision without the pressure of an imminent standard variable rate.

It also creates options. You may be able to secure a product while retaining the ability to reassess if circumstances materially change before completion. The precise approach depends on the lender, the proposed product and your current mortgage terms, so timing should form part of the advice rather than be an afterthought.

Where personal mortgage advice adds value

Mortgage decisions are rarely just about this month’s payment. They affect future borrowing, moving plans, household security and the ability to adapt when life changes. An adviser can assess products from a broad range of high-street and specialist lenders, explain the true costs and support the process from application through to completion.

At Illingworth Mortgages, the focus is on helping clients find a suitable mortgage and reviewing arrangements as circumstances develop. That can be particularly valuable where income is complex, the property falls outside standard lending criteria or the apparent cheapest deal comes with restrictions that do not fit your plans.

Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.

The strongest mortgage choice is not necessarily the one with the boldest rate on an advert. Give yourself time to compare the full cost, test the deal against your plans and seek clear advice before committing. A mortgage that remains suitable after the initial excitement of a house move has passed is usually the deal that serves you best.

YOUR PROPERTY MAY BE REPOSSESSED IF YOU DO NOT KEEP UP REPAYMENTS ON YOUR MORTGAGE.

Not sure where to start?

Tell us what you are planning. A short call is usually enough to map out your options.